Battle of the Bottles–Starbucks vs. Nestle

California may be in the middle of a historic drought, but that hasn’t stopped the bottled water companies from pumping California water.  Until, maybe, now.

The non-profit Courage Campaign ( has collected more than 150,000 signatures for an online petition demanding that the California Water Resources Control Board immediately shut down the water bottling plants of Nestle, which produces such brands as Arrowhead and Pure Life.  The company has five bottling plants in the state.  All told, there are 108 bottling plants in California.

Nestle has countered that it has invested $7 million in water savings projects in California, including conservation programs at its water, milk, and ice cream plants.  Its bottled water plants and its four food factories consume about a billion gallons of water a year, which is less than one one-hundredth of one percent of the state’s annual water use.  That doesn’t seem like much–but, says Peter Gleick of the Pacific Institute (an environmental think tank that focuses on water issues), “It doesn’t absolve bottlers of the overall negative consequences of the bottled water industry.”

Adding to the problem is that one of Nestle’s California plants is located on lands leased from the Morongo Band of Mission Indians in Cabazon.  While a tribe spokesman says that Morongo “strictly monitors the tribally owned wells used by the plant,” there is no statewide or federal agency which tracks exactly how much water is being used.

Another thing–Nestle’s permit to transport water across the San Bernardino National Forest for bottling expired in 1988.  While Nestle submits reports on its water usage to the Forest Service, no water agency knows how much groundwater the company has been using since 2009, the last year the company submitted annual reports to local water districts.

Anger and outrage can be good…it is getting some people involved.  And not just by signing an online petition.  In March, activists in South Sacramento blockaded all truck entrances to Nestle’s bottling plant there, the second such protest in the past year.  Nestle says that in 2014, it used 50 million gallons from the Sacramento Municipal Water Supply, and pays the same rate for water as other businesses.

Wal-Mart’s Great Value bottled water comes from DS Services of America, which buys its water from Sacramento as well.

We should not be bottling our limited water and shipping it out of this state.  At a minimum, we need to reform the bottled water rules and guidelines, and start enforcing transparent reporting.

Starbucks, meanwhile, announced last week that due to drought conditions, the company will no longer source or produce its Ethos Water in the state.  Instead, the operation will be moved to Pennsylvania.  California’s Placer County, the source of the spring water, declared a water shortage emergency last month.  I think Starbucks was beginning to feel the pressure.  Some critics don’t believe Starbucks deserves much credit, since they should not have been bottling in the first place, and the whole thing smacks of a PR move.  But I say, “Bravo, Starbucks!”

In other bottling news, Crystal Geyser Water Co. has announced a plan to pump out thousands of gallons a day from an aquifer that feeds the Sacramento River.  The company does not need a permit from the state, nor an environmental impact report, as California currently does not regulate ground water.  That lack of a solid ground water management plan is a serious oversight.  Combine that with an ancient water rights system, and the whole problem gets trickier.  And I think we are all aware of the negative environmental impact all those plastic bottles have made both during their manufacturing and in their disposal (or lack thereof).

Hurray to Starbucks and I only hope the others follow.  And you, dear reader–stop buying bottled water.  Tap water is almost always of better quality than bottled, and those reusable bottles are super cute!

39 Comments on Battle of the Bottles–Starbucks vs. Nestle

  1. wow, awesome forum topic.Thanks Again. Will read on… Thilmony

  2. This design is spectacular! You obviously know how to keep a reader entertained. Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Great job. I really enjoyed what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it. Too cool!

  3. Thanks, I appreciate it!

  4. What do you want to do when you’ve finished? benzacne cena w aptece But Pfizer has said it will first need to closely analyzethe operations of its patent-protected and generic drugs, as ifthey were distinct businesses, including audits of theirfinancial operations, before deciding whether to split off thegeneric unit.

  5. I’m self-employed can i buy levothyroxine over the counter According to a source, general manager Brian Cashman reached out last week to Long and the other coaches. Pitching coach Larry Rothschild appeared to be close to a new deal, though no deal had been struck with Long.

  6. Whereabouts in are you from? If Sculley were to put in a bid, the 74-year-old would go head to head against a handful of other big names in technology, including Intel, Lenovo and Blackberry founder Mike Lazaridis, who reportedly is considering joining with parter Douglas Fregin to rescue the struggling phone maker.

  7. Remove card Mrs Bull told the Western Daily Press: “Last winter was terrible. We were actually shivering and were hungry. In 2013, two people who worked all their lives at this have ended up cold and hungry. It's not right.

  8. How much were you paid in your last job? universal medicare centre coimbatore “It seems like an improvement in the euro zone economic datahas stalled. In addition, now that Germany’s election is over,the market could dust off the issues that had fallen out offocus, such as further aid to Greece,” said Masafumi Yamamoto,forex strategist at Praevidentia Strategy.

  9. I’ve got a part-time job kl pharmacy kenton lane “That fire still burns,” Garcia told “NFL AM” on Wednesday. “I’m also realistic, though. I’m 43 years old. Who’s gonna want a 40-plus-year-old quarterback to come back and play for them?”

  10. A Second Class stamp The deal is the latest in a spate of acquisitions in the global telecom sector, which is reshaping an industry struggling in Europe but flourishing in the United States and Asia where prices and profits are higher.

  11. I love this site appin pharmacy opening hours In his General Assembly address on Tuesday, Obama suggested that Rouhani’s overtures could “offer the basis for a meaningful agreement” with Iran but stopped short of offering any softening of sanctions crippling its economy.

  12. I don’t like pubs precio del viagra mexico The state Department of Motor Vehicles said Thursday it would begin to develop regulations required by the new law, which will go into effect January 1, 2015, unless the state determines it can begin issuing the licenses sooner.

  13. It’s a bad line erythromycin 250 mg acne This is a type of cookie which is collected by Adobe Flash media player (it is also called a Local Shared Object) – a piece of software you may already have on your electronic device to help you watch online videos and listen to podcasts.

  14. Insert your card goedkoopste kamagra kopen The resolution does not allow for automatic punitive actionin the form of military strikes or sanctions if Syria does notcomply. At Russia’s insistence, Friday’s resolution makes cleara second council decision would be needed for that.

  15. I’m retired womens best ski boots 2015 Given the US government has no set-asides to fund the care of the elderly (it is at least $85 trillion underfunded to meet the needs of future retirees) I only see covert ways to cull the size of the population for government to handle the problem.  In England they have been withholding water from institutionalized elders until they die of dehydration because they have no budget to care for their elderly.  We are not far from Soylent Green.  

  16. Where are you calling from? seroquel xr 50 mg for insomnia The big difference between people and corporations is that people don’t have a purpose (or if they do we don’t know what it is), and corporations do. Therefore corporations should have greater constraints imposed on them than on people.

  17. I don’t like pubs ancient chinese secrets of youth vitality “You can’t replicate something like this, you can’t force-feed it – it just sort of happens,” director Anthony C. Ferrante said ahead of special midnight “Sharknado” showings in 200 U.S. theaters on Friday.

  18. I love this site pea protein shake diet Ardian said it had not seen a decline in the number ofsellers and expected the potential stock of private equity forsale in the next five years will exceed the money ready toinvest in the secondary sector.

  19. Do you play any instruments? generic.list to generic.ienumerable “Our lawyers are now looking through the (new) law that the president signed … to see if there’s any margin here or widening in the interpretation of the law regarding exempt versus non-exempt civilians,” Hagel said. “Our lawyers believe that maybe we can expand the exempt status.”

  20. I enjoy travelling nova dermatology centreville HONG KONG, August 8 (Reuters) – Shares in mainland Chinesemarkets and Hong Kong rose on Thursday after stronger thanexpected trade data soothed worries over a slowdown in theworld’s second largest economy.

  21. Three years what is lansoprazole dr 30 mg capsule “The tragic consequences of the Dallas West Nile virus epidemic must not be forgotten,” Ostroff wrote, “for they serve as a cogent reminder of the need to sustain vector monitoring and prevention programs in all communities.”

  22. perfect design thanks ciprofloxacin uses and dosage Rights groups say Azerbaijan’s strategic location between Russia and Iran, its oil reserves, Europe-bound energy pipelines and its role as a transit route for U.S. troops to reach Afghanistan have cushioned it from Western criticism.

  23. I’ve got a part-time job prescription drugs prices michigan With 62 percent of military sexual assault victims saying they were retaliated against for reporting the assault, action is being taken to better protect those who come forward to report these crimes. To create an environment that encourages victims to report, and to support them when they report these crimes, our legislation builds upon previous bills to require the military to provide qualified and specially trained lawyers to victims of sex-related offenses. Survivors will have a dedicated legal specialist by their side to shepherd them through the legal process and improve their ability to seek justice more effectively.

  24. Remove card now testojack 100 reviews “Let us have the strength to face the threats that endure, different though they may be from 12 years ago, so that as long as there are those who would strike our citizens, we will stand vigilant and defend our nation,” Obama said.

  25. I like watching TV yohimbine side effects men Still, analysts say the misfires could prompt a parade offilm writedowns for studios – a black eye for an industry thatprides its public image nearly as highly as its private jets andsummers in Europe. Janney Montgomery Scott analyst Anthony Wiblesays Disney will likely be forced to take a writedownfor the Johnny Depp western “The Lone Ranger,” and Sony for the sci-fi adventure “After Earth” with Will Smith.

  26. Sorry, you must have the wrong number staytal zydus
    “The laser is not affected by the color or surface of clothes or luggage,” Dantus added. “The resonant pulse and the shadow pulse are always in balance unless something is detected. Our method has Raman chemical specificity, excellent sensitivity and robust performance on virtually all surfaces.”

  27. Would you like a receipt? comprar priligy generico “The difficult actions we are proposing to take will, if implemented, better position the company to support and fund our next chapter of growth while further strengthening our world-leading brands,” it added.

  28. What sort of music do you like? extagen uk shop “We’re excited to partner with Lookout to bring an additional level of security to Samsung Knox. Lookout is the leader in mobile threat protection, and through attachment scanning and safe browsing, they are uniquely equipped to address business mobile security and the evolving challenges in the BYOD movement,” Dr Injong Rhee, senior vice president of Knox at Samsung, said at the time.

  29. International directory enquiries permethrin goodrx Brian White and Paul Taylor of Shore Capital said Mr Lowth’s departure from AstraZeneca “represents probably the final element of senior board changes at the company following the departures of the Chairman and the CEO”.

  30. I read a lot what is toprol xl 25mg used for The FTSEurofirst 300 index of top European sharesclosed 0.14 percent higher at 1,210.70 points, after rising toas high as 1,213.24 points during the session, the index’shighest level since early June.

  31. Can you put it on the scales, please? dimana beli viagra di jakarta “I told Brandon, ‘Man, you need to grow up and figure out that you need to marry this girl,’” Shelton said shortly after Clarkson announced the engagement in December. “I am going on the record saying. . . whatever you want to do, I’ll be that guy.”

  32. Would you like a receipt? prix traitement roaccutane “If you a borrower who focuses on the all-in yield of a bondissue, then there’s an opportunity to get something done nextweek while rates remain stable and before they could conceivablygo back up again once there is a resolution to the debtceiling,” said a syndicate manager at a Wall Street bond house.

  33. I’m not working at the moment review “My tech ‘rules’ for Asher are simple because he’s so young,” she writes. “I try to limit iPhone and iPad screen time to when we’re outside the house. I use these devices to distract him and prevent fussiness at a restaurant or on a long plane ride, for example.

  34. Could you tell me the dialing code for ? dimana beli pil kb yasmin Obama has directed U.S. officials to try to work out anagreement with Iran to allay international concerns about itsnuclear program, an opportunity he has said is worth exploringafter the election of the relatively moderate Iranian PresidentHassan Rouhani.

  35. Which year are you in? The study authors say that it was already common knowledge that remote ischaemic preconditioning helps reduce injury to heart muscle, but they add that this study is the first randomized control trial to provide evidence that the procedure encourages longer survival in coronary bypass patients.

  36. A law firm calcitriol goodrx Hersman said one of the pilots reported being blinded by aflash of light when the plane was 500 feet (152 meters) off theground as it approached the airport. She offered no theory as towhat might have caused such a flash.

  37. An accountancy practice lipstik maybelline red my lips Unlike past tests, the BoE said it intended to publish theresults of its future checks, perhaps bank-by-bank, havingalready crossed this bridge after detailing its capital demandsfor named lenders earlier this year.

  38. Gloomy tales 2006 yamaha yzf r1 performance parts Wedding bells are ringing for Melissa Etheridge! The 52-year-old rocker announced plans to marry her longtime partner, producer Linda Wallem, after the Supreme Court struck down the Defense of Marriage Act on June 26, 2013. “I look forward to exercising my American civil liberties,” Etheridge tweeted. “And getting fully, completely and legally married this year to my true love of over three years, Linda Wallem.” The singer also shared the happy news during a phone interview with CNN, saying, “I’m going to get married in the state of California.” Etheridge, who shares custody of her 7-year-old twins with ex Tammy Lynn Michaels and also has two children from a previous relationship, has been dating Wallem since 2010.

  39. I’d like to tell you about a change of address cialis tadalafil 5mg prix It added that advertising was picking up in the current quarter compared to last year, when it suffered in the shadow of the Olympics on the BBC. The rivalry between BT and BSkyB’s pay-TV sport offerings has also boosted the advertising market recently.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.